Understanding Expansion Valves in HVAC Systems
Expansion valves are critical metering devices in refrigeration and air conditioning systems, designed to precisely inject refrigerant into the evaporator at conditions that enable optimal heat absorption. These components create the pressure drop necessary to convert high-pressure liquid refrigerant to a lower-pressure, lower-temperature mixture that can effectively absorb heat in the evaporator.
Professional HVAC technicians know that proper expansion valve selection and operation significantly impacts system efficiency, capacity, and compressor longevity. These valves are sized to match the calculated load on the system evaporator under standardized conditions, ensuring balanced system performance.
While the HVAC industry uses various expansion valve designsfrom simple orifices and manual hand valves to sophisticated electronic variantsthey all fall into two fundamental categories: fixed and adaptive. Understanding the differences between these categories is essential for proper system design, installation, and troubleshooting.
Fixed orifice expansion valves are simple devices with a non-adjustable opening that cannot actively adapt refrigerant flow to match changing evaporator heat loads. While the amount of refrigerant they inject does vary with pressure differential, this variation isn’t purposefully aligned with changing heat loads.
The most common fixed orifice devices include pistons and capillary tubes. Pistons are essentially precision-drilled metal inserts held in a distributor attached to the evaporator inlet. Image 1 shows a piston (B) and its accompanying distributor. The orifice size and pressure differential across the piston determine refrigerant flow volume.
When sizing fixed expansion devices, manufacturers use “standard conditions”predetermined values for evaporator and condensing pressures, superheat, and subcooling. For example, ARI A/C CT 130F specifies a 45F evaporator temperature, 130F condensing temperature, 20F useful superheat, and 15F subcooling. These standardized conditions allow manufacturers to match components based on capacity for proper system integration.
Since the pressure differential between condensing and evaporator pressures governs flow through a piston orifice, changing conditions directly impact refrigerant flow. This explains why evaporator superheat values vary with outdoor temperatures. On charging charts for piston-equipped air conditioning systems, you’ll notice that superheat target values increase as outdoor temperatures decrease.
During hot, low-humidity days, evaporator superheat can drop to single digits. Coupled with a dirty condenser or poor airflow, this condition can lead to compressor flooding. Conversely, on cooler, rainy days, higher superheat may result in inadequate dehumidification.
Common Fixed Expansion Valve Issues
Fixed expansion valves typically experience these failure modes:
Clogging or Restriction: Debris, oil, or contaminants can partially or completely block the piston or capillary tube, restricting refrigerant flow and causing high superheat, reduced capacity, and poor cooling.
Sizing Issues: An incorrectly sized fixed orifice can’t be adjusted in the field. Oversized pistons or shorter-than-specified capillary tubes lead to evaporator flooding and compressor damage, while undersized components cause starved evaporators and efficiency loss.
System Mismatch: Fixed expansion devices perform optimally only within a narrow range of operating conditions. When ambient temperatures or loads deviate significantly from design parameters, system performance suffers noticeably.
Dislodged Pistons: Improper installation or pressure surges can dislodge piston orifices from their seats, causing erratic refrigerant flow and unpredictable superheat readings.
Capillary tubeslong, narrow-diameter tubingoffer minimal adaptability to condenser pressure changes. In systems with critical charge, increasing condensing pressure reduces subcooling, causing refrigerant to flash to vapor earlier in the capillary tube. Since vapor occupies more volume than liquid, this phenomenon restricts flow through the tube. Nevertheless, capillary tubes still perform best with stable high and low-side pressures.
Proper capillary tube sizing involves selecting the recommended diameter and precisely cutting it to the specified length based on the calculated load. Incorrect sizing invariably leads to improper refrigerant flow and system performance issues.
Listen to Jamie Kitchen and Gary McCreadie discuss superheat as it pertains to adaptive vs. fixed metering devices and subscribe to the HVAC Know It All Podcast.
Unlike fixed metering devices, adaptive expansion valves actively respond to changing evaporator loads by modulating refrigerant flow. This dynamic adjustment capability makes them ideal for applications with variable load conditions or wide ambient temperature ranges.
The most common adaptive valve is the thermal expansion valve (TXV). This mechanical device uses pressure signals from a sensing bulb at the evaporator outlet and from the evaporator itself to regulate refrigerant flow. As shown in Image 2, these pressure signals create opposing forces across a diaphragm in the TXV’s power element.
The key forces at work in a TXV include:
– Opening Force: Pressure from the sensing bulb applied to the top of the diaphragm
– Closing Forces: Evaporator pressure and superheat spring pressure applied to the bottom of the diaphragm
How TXVs Respond to Changing Loads
When evaporator load increases, refrigerant boils off sooner in the evaporator circuit, resulting in higher superheat at the outlet. This heats the sensing bulb, increasing its pressure. This pressure transmits through the connecting capillary tube to the TXV power head and onto the diaphragm’s upper surface.
As this opening force overcomes the combined closing forces of the evaporator pressure and superheat spring, the valve opens wider. The resulting increase in refrigerant flow reduces outlet superheat, creating a self-regulating feedback system.
The superheat spring ensures a minimum superheat level to protect the compressor from liquid flood-back. Adjusting the superheat setting changes the spring force applied. However, technicians should avoid adjusting TXV superheat settings until ruling out other potential issues, as improper adjustments can complicate straightforward repairs.
For multi-circuit evaporators, distributors (see Image 1) create significant pressure drops between the TXV outlet and evaporator outlet. To compensate, these applications require external equalized TXVs, which sample pressure from the evaporator outlet after all pressure drops have occurred. This pressure feeds to the underside of the TXV diaphragm through a connection tube (see Image 3).
Without external equalization, the temperature equivalent of the pressure drop would be added to the required superheat, causing the TXV to underfeed the evaporator. While you can use an external equalized TXV when unnecessary, never use an internal equalized TXV when external equalization is required.
TXV Troubleshooting Guide
When diagnosing TXV issues, monitor these key indicators:
- High Superheat, Low Suction Pressure: Typically indicates a restricted or underfeeding TXV. Check for:
- Plugged inlet screen
- Moisture or contaminants in the valve
- Loss of sensing bulb charge
- Incorrectly mounted sensing bulb
Improperly adjusted superheat setting
Low Superheat, High Suction Pressure: Suggests an overfeeding TXV. Inspect for:
- Sensing bulb improperly located or insulated
- Damaged power head
- Debris preventing valve from closing
Incorrectly adjusted superheat setting
Hunting (Oscillating Superheat): Points to an unstable TXV operation. Examine:
- System refrigerant charge
- TXV oversizing
- Poor sensing bulb contact or location
- Excessive pressure drop across the distributor
Electronic expansion valves (EEVs) represent the most sophisticated metering device technology, combining a valve body with a motor or solenoid and a programmable controller. These systems use pressure and temperature sensors to calculate evaporator saturation temperature and superheat, then precisely adjust valve position accordingly.
EEVs offer unprecedented flexibility across applications from low-temperature freezers to comfort cooling. While many EEVs maintain a fixed superheat value optimized for specific operating conditions, advanced models continuously minimize superheat while maintaining stability, maximizing energy efficiency (see Image 4).
EEVs come in two primary designs:
Stepper Motor Valves: These valves use incremental motor steps to precisely position the valve opening. The stepper motor rotates in calculated incrementsclockwise to close and counterclockwise to openbased on controller signals. Technicians can program opening/closing speeds and set minimum/maximum opening ranges for optimized performance. (Image 5)
Pulse Width Modulated (PWM) Valves: These robust solenoid valves operate either fully open or fully closed. The controller rapidly cycles the valve, with the ratio of open-to-closed time determining effective refrigerant flow. While offering excellent oil return, PWM valves should be installed away from other line components to prevent liquid hammer phenomena.
Energy Efficiency Comparison: TXV vs. EEV
The primary efficiency advantage of EEVs over TXVs lies in their ability to maintain lower stable superheat values:
- TXVs typically maintain 8-12F superheat for stable operation
- EEVs can safely operate with 5-8F superheat
This 3-7F reduction in superheat translates to approximately 2-5% improvement in system efficiency because:
- Lower superheat means more effective evaporator surface area dedicated to the boiling process instead of superheating vapor
- Higher suction gas density entering the compressor improves compression efficiency
- More precise control during part-load conditions minimizes compressor cycling
For a typical commercial refrigeration system, this efficiency gain can reduce annual energy consumption by 400-700 kWh per compressor horsepowersignificant savings that often justify the higher initial cost of EEV technology.
Diagnosing expansion valve issues requires precision. What if you had homeowner insights before you arrived? Property.com offers exclusive members access to the ‘Know Before You Go’ tool, providing permit history, home value, and potential upgrade savings. Elevate your service calls and stand out with Property.com certification. Limited spots available per region secure your advantage today.
Conclusion
Fixed metering devices excel in consistent operating conditions where evaporator loads remain relatively stable. Their simplicity makes them cost-effective for many applications, but they require careful selection to prevent compressor flooding or evaporator starvation when conditions vary.
Adaptive metering devices offer superior flexibility by dynamically matching refrigerant flow to changing loads and ambient conditions. TXVs provide excellent control, throttling down to 50% of rated capacity while capable of delivering up to 30% above rated capacity when needed. EEVs take this adaptability further, controlling loads down to 20% of rated capacity or less while offering greater energy efficiency through precise superheat management.
The selection between fixed and adaptive expansion valves should consider application requirements, operating condition variability, efficiency goals, and budget constraints. For systems experiencing wide load fluctuations or operating in variable ambient conditions, the performance benefits of adaptive valves typically justify their higher initial cost through improved efficiency, reliability, and compressor protection.
Learn More with HVAC Knowitall
Elevate your HVAC expertise and outshine your peers by delving into our informative blog articles, listening to our industry-specific podcast, and subscribe to our YouTube channel, where we share valuable insights tailored specifically for HVAC technicians seeking to enhance their business and provide exceptional service.
